Three Things…



We got into an interesting discussion over lunch today, and were trying to come up with three things in the next year that will occur outside the US, but still have a major impact ON the US…


And then the fight started… 🙂


When you have well educated, well read and well traveled folks, it gets interesting, to say the least!!!


And by consensus, I mean the other  ideas (and there were a bunch) got out voted…LOL


Edit- Wrote #1 in a hurry, left out important words… My bad… Now corrected. 


Consensus idea 1.  Israel ATTACKS (possibly nukes) Iran-  Forces re-evaluation of foreign policy and military drawdown; administration fails…


Consensus idea 2. Chavez/Castro/KI Jung die (one or all)- Russia (Putin) moves to secure control of governments, re-enforces communism. Alt 1 Raul Castro is prevented from taking power, Cuba ‘overthrows’ Castro regime, now what???


Consensus idea 3. Greece collapses taking the EU with it, Euro becomes worthless (effectively)-  Major hit to US economy, possible banking collapse(again), with no fallback.  UN effectively dismantled.


Only the first one is mine, the others came from some other folks (and my other two got voted off the island rather quickly)…


Comments? Are we right, wrong, stupid, full of it?  If you had to add ONE idea, what would it be?

Comments

Three Things… — 25 Comments

  1. 1 and 3 highly probable.

    Chavez ticket has been punched and he’s on borrowed time, but not sure about the rest of 2

  2. Proof reading – not!
    Number 1 quite possible.

    Putin WILL find a way to secure Russian borders – Russian main goal for centuries.

    Wild card. Mexico spins out of control. We invade (call it what you will) and, at a minimum, take control of Veracruz.

    Cuba? So long as the sea lanes to NO aren’t threatened, we will leave them alone.

  3. Any of these lead to “martial law” and suspension of elections. We become a dictatorship.

  4. All of the ABOVE? and the comments, as well.
    This Country and the World are in a sorry state.
    Glenn Beck says it’s just ripe for a savior, like AH in 1933 Germany.
    Here, Europe, Russia…pick one.

  5. Interesting intellectual exercise.

    I’m going to go out on a limb and argue against number one. While I will concede that it’s not impossible that it would happen given the fact that the Israelis have proven their willingness to execute preemptive strikes before (1981 bombing of Iraqi reactor), they have shown extreme restraint in limiting themselves to conventional arms. The Israelis can’t afford to lose their holocaust trump card. If they nuke Iran causing 10s or 100s of thousands of deaths, the west will be handed a get out of jail free card for ending support of Israel.

    2. Seems equally improbable but not impossible as 1. I don’t know enough about the internal politics of all three to give an intelligent counter argument though.

    3. This seems to be the most likely possibility of the bunch. I’m not entirely sure that a Greek collapse would domino the entire EU; however, I don’t think the end result will be any less unpleasant or far reaching. I don’t think there is any question that the world economy is boned unless drastic measures are taken and there seems to be a distinct lack of political will power to make the necessary changes. Sad to say, but I expect to see Nero fiddling while Rome burns in my lifetime. Hopefully, I am proven wrong.

    I think it’s a certainty that the UN has outlasted its usefulness and will go the way of the League of Nations before too much longer.

    The other alternative that I see as a possibility is China taking a more aggressive role in military power projection. They were in the process of finishing out a Russian aircraft carrier a while back which could extend their reach.

  6. #1 is the better choice between bad and worse. Once again the Israelis will do something out of self-interest (Osirak, anyone?) that will benefit the world at large.
    #3 seems to be inevitable and I share North’s concern as to the “fallout” at home.
    I’ll take the other side of “Well Seasoned’s” wild card; we will NOT invade Mexico regardless of what happens there.

  7. Well, they are all possible. But which one is the most probably. Given what we know, I’d say that #3 is the most probable. That being said, I don’t think it will happen. But if it does, I do think the UN is toast.

  8. The only way Isreal nukes anything is as a last resort, like they have proof that Iran is about to launch Nukes at them.

    It’s like a mini-MAD thing.

    Chavez IS dying. The power struggle will be interesting.

    I doubt Putin is interested in being a Communist again. He’d have to give up too much power.

    Greece IS collapsing and it will take the Euro with it. That is inevitable.

  9. I don’t see Russia or Mexico collapsing. The cartels/Russian mob will see that as bad for business, and will step in as shadow governments to maintain order, albeit corrupt and ruthless (not that much different from today).

    I don’t see the Israelis using nukes, but I do think they’ll take some action. They can’t afford to let Iran develop nuclear weapons. Israel has already launched covert attacks, including cyberwar (the Stuxnet worm) and assassinations (sounds like a James Bond film). The next step could very will be direct military intervention

    If I had to add one scenario it would be the likelihood that the Germans get fed up with all the ongoing Euro nonsense, get tired of propping up failed socialist governments, and start building up their military. They can’t help it – it’s in their DNA… 🙂

  10. Well, after reading about all the Hemmin’ and Hawin’ at the G-20 over Greece and the Eurozone and the IMF, it’s looking like ITALY is about to go down the Tubes, and the consensus is the whole House of Cards over there can only be Propped up by the CHICOMS. Even Obama said, “T.S., the U.S. is Broke. Look somewhere else.”

    Iran, who knows? The Assahollahs think Achmeddiditinajar is too soft, and he may be kicked out and Persia just gets run by the Mullahs. Then, from that point on, that’ll depend on how much more the House of Saud is willing to put up with. And Putin’s Goal is to be Tzar of all the Russias, so I wouldn’t look for the re-appearance of the Comintern any time soon.

    But stay tuned to something other than what Kim Kardashian’s Wedding cost. Real News is still happening out there, just a lot harder to find it.

  11. Oh, that had to be one interesting conversation!

    I really don’t know enough in the Middle East to predict what’s going to happen next – other than things will change, and probably for the worse.

    Number 2 I see as inevitable, if not immediately impending – the only thing worse than an insane dictator is the scramble in the vacuum of power the leave. Even if Cuba or Venezuela’s power struggles don’t directly affect us (and from shipping lanes and oil production, they really do), the failure of socialism / communism is a failure of Obama’s ideology, and he’ll not react well to that.

    For an alternate to three – Germany has made noises about taking fiscal ownership of other member states if they should bail them out again. In which case they conquer by the ledger instead of the gun – whether they want that territory or not. And just as sure as feudal lords avoided repaying loans by declaring pogroms, someone’s going to turn it into a shooting match against Germany. Their militaries may be near-vestigial, if they’re all drawn down, it may look like a good enough shot to try.

    What are the odds that if shooting starts, Putin will join in to sweep up former parts of the USSR under “stabilizing the borders”?

    The other worry I have is China – when their bubble bursts, they have so very far to fall. Many a government has distracted its citizens from domestic problems by a “neat little war” – and they have always considered the ROC a rogue province, and have plenty of old grudges against Japan and the West.. as well as an eye to Yuzhno-Sakhalinsk, where there’s plenty of oil waiting to be tapped. If Obama bows out after the first strike, what’s to stop them from “securing their borders” and their neighbor’s resources?

    If you’d tell me I’m worrying over nothing and mean it, I’d be grateful if you’d show me why.

  12. First, let me apologize, I screwed up #1, it SHOULD have said attacks (possibly nukes)… sigh…

    Matt, #2 IS the weird one…

    WSF- Yeah, yeah… 🙂 We did talk about Mexico, but that one got voted off too. Good points though.

    North- Hadn’t thought about THAT option… damn.

    Guffaw- Concur

    Shepard- You are correct on #1, I mis-stated it. Your #4 was my #2, I think THAT is going to happen in 2012 tied in with Taiwanese Elections.

    BG- We didn’t go down that road, but I do see your point!

    Andy- Dunno, it all depends on Germany…

    Alan- Good points, thanks!

    Tim- See my correction above 🙂 And the militarized Germany IS an interesting point, none of us though of that either.

    Les- You have to remember Putin IS KGB, he/they are ALL about total control…

    Wing- It was! And your Germany point is again one we missed, your China point is valid and it was probably the #4 idea if we’d gone that far. Due to what we ‘do’, we left that one on the table, just to be safe.

    Again, my apologies for screwing up #1

  13. Beyond Greece in scenario #3, you have Germany pulling out of the EU, causing France to follow them and the house of cards to collapse. Greece, Ireland, Spain and Portugal are all on the ropes but there is a considerable groundswell of public opinion inside Germany to go it alone.

    If I was a German, I’d side with that sentiment. Return to the Mark (the way that the UK kept the Pound and Switzerland kept the Swiss Franc).

    ***
    Everyone knows when the revolution will come in Mexico (mañana). They can’t make a decision to save themselves. So they’ll put it off, drink some tequila and have a siesta.

  14. Iran’s nuclear plants have terrible accidents killing most of the Nork and Iranian technical staff. Mossad headquarters has a quiet celebration. Western media so busy trying to prove it was Mossad they let Cain win the election.

    Kim is deposed by his own military for a guaranteed supply of Happy Meals.
    Fidel brothers enjoy a long retirement in Spain while Cuba enjoys the fruits of Dade County style politics. Batista laughs from the grave.
    Chaves’ funeral is attended by Jimmy Carter, Michael Moore, et. al. TMZ provides 24/7 coverage.

    The EU collapses and the tumbrels make quick work of Brussels, The Hague and Strasbourg.

    Drug lords, having a better grasp of business than politicians, put Mexico on a firm financial footing. American forced to do work they would not otherwise do as millions of Mexicans return home.

    Vladimir I, Czar of all the Russias, makes peace with Poland and Finland after his unsuccessful attempt to extend Russia’s eastern borders.

    Stretch adds to his ammo supply ’cause he knows no amount of sarcastic humor will make the coming collapse any easier.

  15. I think #3 is the most immediately likely. I agree with Wing and a Whim that Germany might step in and take the whole European tamale with Russia retaking USSR territory, especially since the present administration punted on the missile defense system for Poland.

  16. I’m sorry, I didn’t proofread my comment well enough. I meant to say that all of Europe’s armies are fairly vestigial, but that’s enough of a level playing field that a country finding itself under German fiscal ownership might think theirs is close enough to Germany’s to be willing to take the shot.

    With the edit to #1 – that’s almost a given, though Iran’s not the only target. Israel is more likely to move covertly, since they’ve relied on world opinion in the past – but the more we snub them, the less likely they are to give a damn what we think or say. They’re in a war for their survival, no matter what the media portray – and I’ll guarantee that they’ll strike first if they can, and overwhelmingly hard if they can’t. The problem with a religious government is that the government policy is forced by the dictates of their religion – and as the Muslim Brotherhood rises to power, their new states will be forced to take action against Israel whether it’s wise or not.

  17. All these little details the students of 50-100 years from now will have to memorize…whatever language that may be
    Q

  18. You left out India/Pakistan nuclear exchange. And the damage it will do to the orient and the trade and therefore the economies of China and then the US.

  19. Putin never left power just changed tittles. already put up a trial ballon fir an EU style colition of Warsaw Pac countries.

    Fidel has the charisma, but Raul is the brains. Raul already loosened a lot of the restrictions and made nice with the populous. He isn’t going any where.

    Chavis dies Columbia want let it get to out of hand and might use it as an excuse to step a cross the border and step on FARK that has been hiding just across the border.

    From what I know the sites that Israel would wan’t to hit from the air are hardened against that. But makes them perfect targets for ground forces and tactical nukes, as what them hard to hot from the air wil contain the blast and fallout.

    There want be a succession war in North Korea as China will suport the designated heir.

    Pakistan now there’s a wild card. Pakistan and Afghanistan are looking more and more to China to geel a viod when we leave, or so I’ve heard.

    Hmmmm….

  20. Stretch- Good points!

    MC- Very possible and not good

    Wing- Copy all, that whole roofpreading thing bit me too 🙂

    Quiz- Probably…LOL

    BrB- Excellent point!

    Josh- Good points too, thanks!

  21. Like many others here I agree all scenarios are possible. And I’ll chime in with Wing/Whim about keeping a close eye on China. When the world falls apart and there is no market for all their plastic gee-jaws, the Chinese will be looking for a way to continue the standard of living they’ve become accustomed to. They’re already making inroads into space…
    And that means they have the ability to smite us without difficulty.

    History is a bitch. And anytime things get this unsettled, history shows it can get much, much more unsettled before it gets better. The major difference between now, and the recent past? Britain no longer could mount the sort of offensive they built in order to retake the Falklands, so they won’t be much help when the fur starts flying. We’re cutting back on budgets for the very weapons systems we’ll need to punish our enemies.

    I hope my crystal ball is wrong.

  22. Greybeard

    I made a post not to long ago with these numbers

    1 and 3.

    5 and 20%

    There are 3 almost 4 Chinese for every American.

    They also save 20% their income vs. our 5%.

    This means they have the population am cash reserves to buy their own goods.

    The only reason I can think of as to why they haven’t done it already is they are waiting for our dollar to crash. So they can step in as the new world reserve curancy.

    Hmmmm……