Train like you fight???

As I prepare to teach my first class as a certified pistol instructor, I’ve been talking to a number of folks whom I respect about training both at the basic level (where I will be), and more advanced classes.  The conclusion I’ve come to, and bolstered by a number of others, is that we can’t really do it right…

These are my thoughts, so take them with a grain of salt (or truckload)…

The Four Rules (compressed to three in the NRA instructions)

RULE I: ALL GUNS ARE ALWAYS LOADED.

RULE II: NEVER LET THE MUZZLE COVER ANYTHING YOU ARE NOT WILLING TO DESTROY.

RULE III: KEEP YOUR FINGER OFF THE TRIGGER UNTIL YOUR SIGHTS ARE ON THE TARGET.

RULE IV: BE SURE OF YOUR TARGET, AND WHAT IS BEHIND IT.

What do I mean?  Well, we face a number of limitations any time we go to a range (for the purposes of this discussion range= square range, e.g. most indoor and outdoor ranges…

Obviously, first and foremost is the requirement for safety.  Staying behind the red line, only pointing weapons in a safe direction, shooting at a standard target that isn’t moving (or very limited movement at a steady pace).  Slow fire only (seeming to become more prevalent these days), no observers on the firing line, etc.

If you’re teaching more than one person, everyone does the same drill at the same time’; with one or more instructors observing from behind the line.  Good instructors will do multiple drills to get a chance to observe each person doing the drill; but the maxim of teaching to the 50th percentile means you’re losing the top and bottom 10% (or more) of the class due to either boredom or never grasping the drill, or unacknowledged fear of the drill/weapon).

Even the simple things- proper grip, trigger pull (or press if you will), trigger reset, and sight alignment are sometimes not taught as a single evolution, but as pieces/parts.  One lady I helped had been through a ‘basic pistol’ class (don’t know the certification or instructor qualification), but after EVERY shot she had been told to completely remove her finger from the trigger immediately, regrip the pistol and while she was doing that to look at see where she’d hit the target (colloquially known as ‘prairie dogging’).  But that was all in the name of range safety…

I do believe in the Barney Fife if someone has never shot a pistol, but to effectively ‘train’ someone to Barney Fife themselves just doesn’t make sense.

Coming from rifle shooting for many years, I’m leaning toward three shot sequences, to work grip, trigger press, reset and sight picture.  Also I’m not too proud to borrow from others, like Bill at EIAFT (I highly recommend this particular post as he has links to all the basics if you have some time to peruse it), he showed me a neat training trick with a ball point pen that I will also use.

The other things that I consider limitations are the Bell Curve of knowledge that one encounters with students; another is the fact that it is hard to put yourself in the student’s place, e.g. limited to no knowledge and remember when YOU were there. It takes patience and understanding to be a good instructor and answer the same ‘dumb’ question twenty times.  Also, what ‘we’ assume everyone knows since ‘we’ know it, is often not true or is completely unknown/foreign to basic students. In this I do give a lot of credit to the NRA courses for bringing the material down to basics and their instructor guides that ‘make’ one teach the actual basics at the correct level.  There are also issues with personal dynamics in any class setting that one must manage, but that is a whole nuther discussion as they say…  And when you add in male, female, young and old in the same class… Patience is a virtue and it takes a good instructor to draw out those reticent students to make sure they are actually getting the materials.

At the basic level, what are we really trying to do?

I think it boils down to three things-

1.  Basic knowledge and safety- How to handle a weapon (handguns in this case) safely, safety rules, teaching the different types of handguns and their basic functions (loading/unloading, functions and function checks, safety, trigger types, cleaning and storage).

2.  Fundamentals of shooting (or marksmanship if you will)- dominant eye determination, stance(s), the grip, sighting and sight alignment, and trigger techniques. This is where I believe the advent of various training weapons like the SIRT, or Laserlyte inserts or pistols are a great assist to the instructor, because you CAN do one on one training in a classroom environment and ensure that step 2 above has actually absorbed and understood by the student in a safe environment before you go on the range.  (And as an aside, they make great training/dry fire tools when one can’t get to the range, example HERE.)

3. Practical shooting-  Talking with folks like Bill, Keads, and others, there seems to be a split in whether one uses a blank piece of paper for the student to shoot at, or giving them an actual bullseye to shoot.  One thing that does seem to be common, is using some type of .22 pistol as the basic trainer.  Ruger and now the advent of .22 trainers from a variety of manufacturers has made this much easier.  But it also helps to have a .22 revolver because some students may only have access to that type of handgun (see item one above).  If folks bring their own pistols, you need to make damn sure they are unloaded and safed before coming on the range (As an aside here, I was assisting an instructor a couple of years ago in a classroom session and a lady brought in the pistol her husband had given her for the training. She started to take it out of the rug and I asked her if she had safed the pistol. She didn’t know what I was asking and handed the rug to me.  I went to the back of the room (safe area) and opened the rug. In it was a .45 Colt, loaded, one in the chamber cocked and the safety off!!!). I would still start them on a .22 until they’ve done the basic drills.  Then if time permits, you can run a quick function check on the pistol they brought and give them personal attention while they shoot it.  One does NOT want to have the student leave the class scared of recoil… Just sayin…

Now, where do we go from here?

There are a number of both CCW and home defense courses available, in addition to what I will call advanced courses given by instructors all over the USA.  More and more women are becoming instructors and teaching more women self defense courses with a female perspective, which I for one, think is a good idea!  One can also take 2-5 day courses from a variety of places, organizations and individuals (too many to list, you can look em up, and I don’t want to piss anybody off by inadvertently leaving them off a list).

One of the things I believe is that as basic instructors we must be careful of the dichotomy of basic level training and saying these are the ONLY rules versus the reality of self defense and the real world.  I believe we need to acknowledge and explain to the students the safety we preach and require on the range may not apply in reality and advanced training; e.g. applicable laws of your state; movement, both of ourselves and targets; cover/concealment; and 270 or 360 degree ranges and shoot houses.

Steve Wenger has a great set of points on street vs. range and training HERE, so I won’t belabor those…

What I’ll be teaching is NRA’s The Basics of Pistol Shooting and this is the overview of the course.

Name : NRA Basic Pistol Shooting Course

Short Description : Teaches the basic knowledge, skills, and attitude for owning and operating a pistol safely.

More Details: This course is at least 8-hours long and includes classroom and range time learning to shoot revolvers and semi-automatic pistols. Students learn NRA’s rules for safe gun handling; pistol parts and operation; ammunition; shooting fundamentals; range rules; shooting from the bench rest position, and two handed standing positions; cleaning the pistol; and continued opportunities for skill development. Students will receive the NRA Guide to the Basics of Pistol Shooting handbook, NRA Gun Safety Rules brochure, Winchester/NRA Marksmanship Qualification booklet, take a Basics of Pistol Shooting Student Examination, and course completion certificate.

One thing I will be stressing to the students is go to the range and practice, eight hours does not an expert make, and the more one shoots the more comfortable they become (and the better drilled in the basics of safety, handling and shooting they are). We ARE creatures of habit, and repetition of actions does help ingrain those actions in our hind brain to the point that they become automatic.

Shoot safe, enjoy the range time and realize that shooting is actually a relaxing sport!  The concentration it takes to shoot well forces you to put other things out of our minds, and practice the ‘Zen’ of shooting! Smile

Comments

Train like you fight??? — 22 Comments

  1. I’d love to retake the basics course from you — I’m sure I’d learn a lot!

    The major comment I would make — and I haven’t even the slightest idea how you will go about it — is to teach your worthy students to respect the gun, but not to fear it. It is a critical difference… and all too often, in the process of teaching safety it is easy enough to instill fear rather than respect. Certainly in the basic NRA course I had to take to get my Connecticut carry permit (which was a hoot!) the instructor — who otherwise did a fine job — managed to get fear across to a number of the newbies, rather than respect. One could see it developing.

    Other thoughts. Do include at least one revolver (two would be better — a double action, say S&W type with a break reload, and a Colt type single action with a gate reload). For some of us that’s what we carry. Also, everyone should get a chance to shoot something with a heavy recoil. There’s a lot to be said for doing most of the work with 22s, but if that’s all you’ve ever shot, your first go with a 9mm or worse a 45 is going to be a shock.

  2. I’ve been teaching shotgun classes for nine years (clay targets…not “social work”). After you have a few classes under your belt, I would be very interested in hearing your opinions on teaching adult males, adult females, and young people. The differences in their respective willingness to listen and follow instructions can be striking.

    There are also some fascinating things happening to eye dominance in the younger generation. Where most adults have one dominant eye, I’ve noticed a distinct increase in co- dominance in young people who play video games on big screen TV’s. Keep some Chapstick in your range bag to occlude one lens of their glasses and watch the scores magically improve.

    Good luck and stick with it! Teaching people to shoot is one of the most rewarding activities I’ve found. It’s all about “the new shooter smile”.

  3. Great post NFO. I concur about the .22 revolver and .22 semi-autos for training. Cheaper to shoot and less recoil for your new shooters. I have students shooting at a B-27 target, but a blank sheet of paper or a blank with a shoot n see stuck on it (especially with small calibers =).

    Good luck and have fun!

  4. Great post!! Looks like you’re ready! I’m really looking forward to the AAR on how it went.

    Have a good time . . . take pictures! 🙂

  5. It has been many years since I went through a gun safety course and I am sure the training is much different now. And since I don’t shoot very often, I think I will check into a refresher course. And enjoy your time on the range… just don’t get too frustrated with a hard-head and show him what pointing a gun other than down range can do.

  6. I always try and remind new shooters that they are allowed to breath. They seem to forget sometimes.

    Good luck and have fun.

  7. Well, here’s something to consider. ChristinaLMT was able to come up to N.H. this past weekend, and she brought her Twin Daughters. 19 years old, one’s a College Freshman, and VERY New Shooters. So a few of us took turns helping them get their “Intro to Guns” out of the way. But one Bad Habit that appeared was their “Let’s Lean Back to Shoot Stance.” That was the biggest issue we had, but Boy Howdy! And it isn’t Chris’s fault, because she has had little time to train them. So just be aware of that “Backward Lean” when you start teaching.

  8. Hey Old NFO;

    Good Post! It is a good thing that you do, you are helping to train and influence the next generation of shooters. Many ranges have safety rules that almost seem to be written by lawyers rather than what is practical. The sssslllooowww fire that is only accepted. How will you train to quickly bring your sight on target when you develop muscle memory of the shooting at the range? Stuff like that. I would love to attend one of those “combat” shooting classes that would be more realistic. But any time at the range is a good thing.

  9. Packed up several pistols and the rifle to drive 1.5 hours to Battle Creek to visit our close friends and ended up enjoying dinner and talking, we never shot!
    Do I need an intervention?

  10. Opus- Lousy!!! .22 may be coming back some places, but not on the east coast…

    Ian- Good points, and I’ve got the revolvers on the list!

    Len- 17 years of military instructor, LOL… But I know there are differences, and I’ll watch that. Also interesting on the dominant eye, hadn’t heard about that, thanks!

    Rev- Thanks!

    Keads- I think I’m going with the blank with a shoot and see… That does seem to work.

    Bill- Thanks, lot of it came from your instruction, thanks for that! Pics if I have time!!!

    CP- Not a bad idea!

    Gerry- Yep, that and leaning back to shoot, rather than nose over toes… sigh

    WSF/PH- Thanks!

    Les- OH yeah, know ALL about that one! Thanks for taking the time to help the kids out!

    BOb- Right on all counts!

    Ed- Yes you do!!! 😀

    Agirl- Debatable… 🙂

  11. Dominant eye – small PostIt notes to cover one lens works, doesn’t leave residue. Put a sign on the classroom door – “NO live ammunition permitted in the classroom at any time. Ask if you don’t know.” Start looking for used but good quality “student guns” in all calibers. Someone will show up with an S&W Airweight or a P3AT and those are lousy to try to learn on. Don’t try to teach too much – your goal in a Basic class is to create safe and competent gun operators. Gun Operators, not shooters. Becoming a Shooter is in the future after they master Basic Gun Operation. After they become a Shooter they can move up to whatever more advanced training they desire. Your instructor notes should refer to the relevant NRA student manual page. If you’re using Powerpoint put the relevant page number in one lower corner of each slide. Maintain a consistent theme for all PP slides – color, layout, typeface; minimal variables makes it easier for students to focus on content. Stance and grip is important. Most of the ladies will lean back – “nose over toes,” back straight, hips back, shoulders forward, knees slightly bent.” You will have to repeat that. A lot. Get a few blue guns in different makes.models, always treat blue guns like real guns. SIRTs are well worth it – I adjust mine to set the red dot below the student’s line of sight with proper sight alignment, the green dot on top of the front sight post. If the red dot is at 6 o’clock and 2″ low at 25 feet they understand sight alignment. Equip a couple student guns with Crimson Trace grips for those students who need some special attention on sight alignment (CT gives NRA Instructors a discount). Mine are adjusted 5″ low and 5″ right; if the dot is 1″ outside the target at 4:30 they understand sight alignment (I use 9″ paper plates on a 24″ X 24″ cardboard backer). If the holes suddenly appear high left they’re using the dot not the sights. Paper plates are cheap, round and have no artificial aiming point, but one can be added with a black paster if needed. A large cardboard backer will help locate shots outside the plate. I set targets at 20 ft, but keep one set at 8-10 ft for those students who need special attention on sights. If the instructor can’t see where the shots are going he or she can’t help the student learn the proper correction. I always carry concealed while teaching; you’ve got X number of people in the room, none of whom you know, and you’re responsible for their safety. If you can, video yourself and review it.

    And have fun. It’s supposed to be enjoyable for both you and the students.

  12. Anon- Thanks! And all good points! I’ll be using the NRA manual, so it’s already set up correctly.

  13. Our household version of Rule 3, as originated, I think, by Lawdog and taught to me in my CHL class, is “Keep your booger-hook off the bang switch”.

  14. The co-dominant eye issue is much more likely to show up on the shotgun field than a short distance pistol range. What appears to be happening is that young people who play lots of video games on big screen TV’s are left eye dominant when presented with an object moving from left to right and right eye dominant with an object moving from right to left. May not make much difference on a fixed target, but it sure plays hell with getting a shooter on target on the skeet field!

    Most readers of this blog probably grew up playing outside, throwing balls (or rocks) to/at their friends, having BB gun wars, and generally raising hell like good kids. Now we have a generation of couch potatoes. Once they realize that real life can be more exciting than a video game they’re hooked, but sometimes they need a little extra help to develop abilities that the rest of us take for granted. You’ll be amazed at how many cannot close only one eye……..hence the need for Chapstick, post-it notes, electrical tape, etc.

  15. You have a good handle on it NFO. Just be you and you’ll do fine. I hope you post an AAR for the class.

  16. Harper- Good point too!

    Len- Thanks, will add those to the ‘toolkit’ so to speak… I appreciate the info and education!!!