Continuing the family things theme…
This came to me through mama’s side of the family, she said this reminded her of one of the places they lived in the 1920s, when she was little…

It’s still in the original frame, and has this ‘doodle’ on the matting… I do remember Grandpa saying they kept a cow or two for milk and food during the Depression. He also said he was lucky, in that he was able to hold his job on the railroad during that time.
My Google-fu came up with this on the artist… Which is strange, as this ‘appears’ to be a more western scene, but apparently he was from upstate New York…
John Hill Millspaugh, born at Crawford in New York State, became a painter and etcher in the late 19th century and earned much respect for the quality of his work. However, he is little known today.
He was raised at Crawford on the Hudson River. At age 16, he went to New York City to apprentice as a stereotyper, which was highly detailed work creating relief plates of metal from original woodcuts. By the mid 1840s, he was working in Waverly as a stereotyper, and then moved to Ithaca where he met his wife, Marion Elizabeth Cornell. Her uncle, Ezra Cornell became exceedingly wealthy from the telegraph business and founded Cornell University.
John had a brother, Edward, who showed early talent as an artist and studied with Henry Inman, a leading Hudson River School painter. He died at age 31 from smallpox. Hoping to carry on his brother’s work, John began studying art, and his most influential teacher was George Lafayette Clough (1824-1901), also a Hudson River School painter.
John Millspaugh’s career between 1851 and 1871 remains undocumented, but according to his obituary, he considered himself an amateur artist. It is thought he made his living during this period as a stereotyper. A description of one of his oil paintings shows a family picnic, and one person reported seeing an etching of Cornell University. The only known painting in a public collection is dated 1872 and is titled “Autumn in the Susquehannock.” It is a pastoral landscape in the Hudson River School style and is in the Palmer Art Museum at Pennsylvania State University.
In 1872, Millspaugh left Ithaca for New York City to take a job for an undetermined period of time at the Customs House. However, his family suffered when a severe depression, the Panic of 1873, hit a year later, and his son had to leave college.
By 1882, he reportedly was getting attention in New York City for his etching, an art form that was extremely popular at that time and tried by many artists. Millspaugh was invited to join the New York Etching Club, the country’s first organization specifically devoted to that medium. His etchings are highly detailed, and most of them depict quiet landscapes. The earliest one published was likely “Evening on the Delaware,” by fine-art publisher Christian Klackner. One of these works is in the Parrish Art Museum at Southampton, Long Island.
Millspaugh collaborated with Boston painter and etcher Louis K Harlow to publish works through Klackner. After 1889, Millspaugh did mostly self publishing. At an undetermined date, he left Manhattan and returned to Ithica to live. He and his wife spent the winter of 1893-94 in Denver, Colorado, and he died on the return trip to Ithaca.
I know there is a term for the little doodle on the matting, but I’ll be dipped if I can remember what it is… Little help???
Remarque is the term you’re looking for.
he went to New York City to apprentice as a stereotyper,
After only three years of school I had a very complete set of stereotypes that haven’t needed any upgrades. I don’t understand the need for an Apprenticeship.
😂
Thing is, relatively small buildings of a certain era might potentially look fairly similar, because of habits of available work force, and easiest path.
Texas versus upstate New York, the critical thing would be the angle of the roof, and of how it is supported. Wildly different expected values for precipitation. You would not be able to see the construction of the roof supports with the framing on with this level of detail.
That bio does imply that he traveled as far west as Colorado. Which could maybe be a quick trip by rail. Parts of Colorado are closer to /north/ Texas than east or south texas are.
I do think that the vegetation details in the foreground /might/ be enough details to place somewhere not upstate New York, but I am basically super ignorant about plants and stuff.
I’m thinking the sketch with the cattle was either done while travelling, or from an observation of another painting or early photograph. Artists sketch; many times at a moments notice. One thing is for sure he was impressed enough to make a sketch, which may have been to do a more elaborate painting in the future.
Howard- That’s it!!! Thank you!
All- Thanks for the details y’all found!
Respect.
Upstate NY is still very rural. It reminds me of the country places we went to as a family 50 years ago before some of the current interstates.
It has water, no so many clouds if you get away from Lake Ontario. If NY State was better run, a great place for data centers.